Choosing Between a Big or Small Audit Firm: What’s Right for Your Business?

When it comes to auditing your company’s financials, choosing the right audit firm is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. Whether you’re a startup, an SME, or a listed enterprise, the choice between a big audit firm (such as the Big Four) and a smaller or mid-tier audit firm can significantly influence your audit experience, cost, and the overall value you get from the process.

So, how do you decide whether to engage a large international firm or a smaller, local audit practice?

In this article, we’ll compare both types of audit firms across key factors including expertise, cost, industry focus, flexibility, and relationship dynamics—so you can make a well-informed decision tailored to your business needs.

---

1. Understanding the Differences

Big Audit Firms:

These include the “Big Four” — PwC, Deloitte, EY, and KPMG — and other large global or regional networks like BDO, RSM, or Grant Thornton. They typically offer a full suite of services including audit, tax, advisory, risk consulting, and cybersecurity.

Small or Mid-Tier Audit Firms:

These firms are usually locally or regionally based and focus primarily on audit, tax, and accounting services. They often work with SMEs, startups, charities, and local corporations.

Each has its own strengths, and the “right” choice depends largely on your business size, stage of growth, and audit objectives.

---

2. Cost Considerations

Big Audit Firms:

• Tend to be more expensive due to their global infrastructure, brand name, and comprehensive processes.

• Suitable for companies with larger budgets or complex financial operations.

• Often charge premium fees for even routine engagements.

Small Audit Firms:

• More budget-friendly and accessible to startups, SMEs, and non-profits.

• Competitive rates for standard statutory audits and tax services.

• May offer flexibility in pricing, especially for long-term relationships.

Verdict: If cost is a significant concern and your company doesn’t have complex global operations, a small audit firm may be a better fit.

---

3. Level of Personal Attention and Service

Big Firms:

• Clients may be handled by a rotating team, and junior staff typically perform much of the fieldwork.

• Access to senior partners may be limited unless you’re a high-value client.

• Processes are standardized and sometimes less flexible.

Small Firms:

• Offer more personalized service with direct access to partners and senior auditors.

• Often build long-term, relationship-driven engagements.

• More responsive and adaptable to client-specific needs.

Verdict: For businesses that value close, consistent communication and tailored service, small firms often shine.

---

4. Expertise and Resources

Big Firms:

• Employ thousands of professionals with deep expertise across industries and regions.

• Have dedicated teams for IFRS, tax structuring, ESG audits, IPO readiness, and M&A advisory.

• Stay ahead of emerging regulations and technological advancements.

Small Firms:

• Strong in general audit and tax knowledge, especially for local regulatory requirements.

• May lack resources for highly specialized or industry-specific audit needs.

• Typically don’t offer in-house advisory, legal, or risk consulting services.

Verdict: If your company is complex, expanding internationally, or operating in a highly regulated sector (e.g., banking, healthcare, tech), a big firm may provide more value.

---

5. Reputation and Credibility

Big Firms:

• Globally recognized brand names that add credibility to your financials.

• Often required by investors, lenders, and regulatory bodies—especially for listed or IPO-ready companies.

• Viewed positively in due diligence and M&A processes.

Small Firms:

• Reputable in their own right, especially if accredited by the local regulator (e.g., ACRA in Singapore).

• Suitable for statutory compliance and internal use, but may not carry the same weight with large international stakeholders.

Verdict: If external stakeholders (e.g., institutional investors, banks, regulators) place importance on who audits your accounts, a big firm may be necessary.

---

6. Industry Experience

Big Firms:

• Serve large multinational clients in virtually every sector—financial services, construction, F&B, manufacturing, logistics, etc.

• Deep industry benchmarking data and tailored audit approaches.

• Sector-specific expertise that adds advisory value beyond the audit itself.

Small Firms:

• Often serve niche markets like SMEs, family businesses, charities, MCSTs, or local franchises.

• Familiar with local market dynamics and Singapore Financial Reporting Standards (SFRS).

• Less likely to have sector specialization for large-scale industries.

Verdict: If your business operates in a highly specialized industry or regulated environment, check if the firm—big or small—has relevant industry experience.

---

7. Flexibility and Turnaround Time

Big Firms:

• Work on strict schedules due to global coordination, peak seasons, and heavy workloads.

• Less flexibility with audit timing, document formats, or scope.

• May have longer turnaround times during busy periods (January to April).

Small Firms:

• More flexible with scheduling and can accommodate last-minute requests.

• Faster response times and quicker audit completion due to leaner teams.

• Often better suited for fast-moving businesses or startups needing agility.

Verdict: If your business values speed, responsiveness, and flexibility, a smaller firm may be more effective.

---

8. Long-Term Partnership Potential

Big Firms:

• May view smaller clients as lower priority unless you’re growing quickly or part of a larger group.

• Partner relationships may be less personal or change frequently due to internal rotations.

Small Firms:

• Invest in long-term relationships and tend to work closely with the same client contact year after year.

• Understand your business intimately and often go beyond basic compliance to offer practical advice.

Verdict: If you’re looking for a trusted advisor, not just a service provider, small firms often excel in long-term partnership building.

---

9. Regulatory Requirements

In some cases, the choice is made for you based on your company’s profile.

• Listed companies, public interest entities, or companies preparing for IPO may be required or strongly encouraged to appoint a Big Four firm.

• Private companies, startups, and small charities or MCSTs usually have complete freedom to choose any firm that is licensed and reputable.

---

Conclusion: Which Is Right for You?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer when choosing between a big or small audit firm. The best choice depends on:

If you’re a growing SME looking for compliance, value, and service, a small to mid-tier firm may be your best bet. If you’re aiming for an IPO, managing complex international operations, or subject to heavy regulatory scrutiny, a big audit firm might be the right fit.

Take the time to speak with both types of firms, request proposals, and choose the one that understands your goals, challenges, and business journey.

Small audit firms are great for small businesses.